From Crew to Boss: Managing Friends, Peers, and Former Co-Workers

The key to going from co-worker to leader is consistency.

Managing Former Coworkers

Stepping into a leadership role is never easy, but it’s especially complicated when the people you’re supervising used to be your equals—or even your friends.

Maybe just last week, you were joking around on lunch break, rolling your eyes at “management,” and helping each other get through a long shift. Now you’re “the boss,” and everything’s changed—even if no one wants to say it out loud.

This chapter is for anyone trying to figure out how to lead people they used to stand beside. It’s not about pulling rank or trying to be someone you’re not. It’s about making the shift—with honesty, respect, and the kind of leadership that earns loyalty instead of resentment.

It Was All Good… Until I Got Promoted

I first experienced this in the Navy. One minute, I was part of the crew. Next, I was put in charge.

Some people were supportive. Others? Not so much.

Some treated me like nothing had changed. Some resented me for being promoted. Some tested the boundaries on purpose, just to see what I would do. Others assumed I’d do everything the same way as before and flipped out when I started changing the process to improve it.

It takes time for people to see you in a new role. And it takes time for you to feel solid in it, too.

The hardest moment? Having to reprimand someone for the first time—someone who used to be my peer. I did it privately, but their look of shock said it all: “You were one of us.”

Yes. I was. But now I had a responsibility.

The Jealousy No One Wants to Talk About

Throughout my life, I’ve struggled with people being jealous when I was promoted, earned a bonus, or got recognition. I’ve lost friendships over it.

Some people who claim to be your friend just can’t be happy for you when you succeed. And when you’re elevated—even for good reason—there’s always someone waiting to knock you off the pedestal you earned.

It hurts. But it’s real. And if you want to lead, you have to deal with it.

The Truth About Leading Your Former Peers

Let’s be honest—it’s awkward. You’re not “one of the gang” anymore. And if you try to pretend nothing has changed, you’ll fail.

Here’s what really shifts when you become the boss:

• You become the enforcer. You have to hold people accountable.

• You can't play favorites. Even if you’re close to someone on the team.

• You represent leadership now. Whether you feel ready or not.

• You’re expected to fix problems. Not complain about them.

Trying to stay “just one of the team” will leave everyone confused—and undermine your ability to lead.

When a Friend Crosses the Line

I’ll never forget the first time I had to discipline someone I was truly close to.

We were both in the Navy. She was my good friend—we hung out off-duty all the time. One morning, she decided not to show up for muster. She’d had fun the night before and didn’t feel like getting up.

I went to wake her up and told her she was late. I warned her: “If you don’t show up, I have to write you up. I don’t have a choice.” She didn’t take me seriously.

So I wrote her up.

She was shocked. She couldn’t believe I did it.

I told her, “It’s not personal. But if it’s between you getting in trouble or me losing credibility, I have to do what’s right. You made the choice.”

She was mad for a while. But she got over it. Because deep down, she knew I was right.

5 Things I’ve Learned About Managing Former Co-Workers

1. You Need a Private Reset Conversation

The group dynamic changes, but individuals still matter. If you’re supervising a friend or peer, have a one-on-one conversation early. Say something like:

“I know this shift in roles is a little weird. I still respect you, and I hope we can work well together. But I want to be upfront—I have to be consistent and fair with everyone now. I hope you understand.”

It clears the air and sets the tone for professionalism.

2. Never Correct in Public, Always Clarify in Private

People will test you more when they think they know you. If someone challenges you in front of the group, don’t get drawn into a public argument. Pull them aside. People often act differently when they’re not in front of an audience.

Group: “I don’t have to do that. That’s not how we’ve done it.”You (later, privately): “Let’s talk about that shift. Things are going to change, and I’m here to make it smoother, not harder. What’s really going on for you?”

3. Don’t Expect Support Right Away

It takes time for people to adjust. Some will support you. Some will be jealous. Some will keep testing your boundaries for weeks or months. Don’t expect instant respect just because you have a title.

Instead, show consistency. Be fair. Communicate changes. Acknowledge their frustrations without backing down.

You earn respect by how you lead, not by demanding it.

4. Speak to the Group, Then Support the Individual

When you start a new leadership role, gather the team. Say something like:

“I know this is a shift. Some of us have worked together for a while. Things may look different going forward. Processes might change. Expectations will be clearer. But my goal is the same as yours: to get the job done well and make this a place we want to work.”

People appreciate honesty. They want to know what to expect. You’re not declaring war—you’re setting direction.

5. When in Doubt, Lead with Clarity

Friendships may or may not survive the promotion. That’s a hard truth.

But your job isn’t to protect friendships—it’s to protect the team’s success.

Be clear. Be calm. Be respectful. If you make a mistake, own it. If someone crosses the line, address it. If someone surprises you by stepping up, praise them.

The more consistent and fair you are, the more people will stop seeing you as “one of us who got lucky” and start seeing you as someone worth following.

Quick Tips for New Supervisors Leading Former Peers

• Don’t gossip—ever.

• Avoid “inside jokes” with former close friends.

• Document everything (especially corrections or praise).

• Keep private conversations private.

• Don’t take early resentment personally.

• Show up the same way every day.

What Research Says About Role Shifts

According to the Harvard Business Review, first-time managers often fail because they try to maintain peer relationships rather than fully stepping into leadership. That creates confusion, cliques, and uneven expectations (Harvard Business Review, 2020).

A SHRM study adds that 44% of new managers feel unprepared for “managing people who used to be peers” (SHRM, 2022). So if you're struggling—you’re not alone.

The good news? With clarity, consistency, and honest communication, most teams adjust and even thrive.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

If you're struggling to lead former friends or peers, you don’t have to figure it all out on your own.

• Use Neighbor Chat to talk it through with someone who understands.

• Try Next Step Services for coaching on how to set boundaries and still lead with heart.

• Join a support group of new supervisors who are figuring this out just like you.

  
  

You can lead well—and still be human. Let’s do it together.

JOIN A GROUP

References

• Harvard Business Review. (2020). Why New Managers Fail. https://hbr.org

• SHRM. (2022). First-Time Manager Challenges. https://www.shrm.org